叮咚叮咚!
2024-2025赛季WSDA秋季赛公共论坛式辩论辩题公布,本次辩题为:
Resolved: "The benefits of the use of generative artificial intelligence in education outweigh the harms."
在教育中使用生成式人工智能的利大于弊。
想必各位辩手都正在紧锣密鼓地筹备中吧,也许此刻你正在前期认真收集相关资料,不断夯实知识理论基础,又或是梳理好观点,仔细打磨相关论据。本次为大家邀请到了Carol老师分享自己对次辩题的看法与解析,Carol老师不仅多次参加过英国议会制辩论赛获得最佳辩手,也曾在多个重要辩论赛事中担任裁判长,拥有丰富的辩论经验。快来查收这份独家秘籍吧~
Carol导师介绍 裁判经历 曾在多个重要辩论赛事中担任裁判长,包括清华校际联合辩论赛、超新星辩论锦标赛等,在辩论赛事领域拥有丰富经验。 辩论经历 多次参加英国议会制辩论赛获得最佳辩手,并入围国际辩论赛事。曾获得广东辩论挑战赛最佳辩手、亚太大学生辩论锦标赛最佳辩手,也是世界大学辩论锦标赛英文非母语组半决赛选手,亚洲联合辩论锦标赛英文非母语组四分之一决赛选手。
Part 01 PF Topic Overview
PF Topic Overview With the development of generative AI technologies such as ChatGPT, DALL-E, generative AI are becoming increasingly common in education. Some believe that generative AI can revolutionize education by personalizing learning and automating tasks, while others raise concerns about students being reliant on AI, potential job replacement and biased education due to the over-adoption of generative AI in education. While the tech-focused motion might seem challenging, it specifically targets education, making it relatable for students who can identify both the opportunities and risks involved. It is crucial to establish comparisons in the debate, considering who will perform the tasks handled by gen-AI instead and whether that alternative is better or worse.
Part 02 Definition
What is generative AI Generative AI is a branch of AI that focuses on generating new content such as Images, Text, Audio, Video based on patterns learned from existing data. Unlike other forms of AI, such as predictive AI, which forecasts future outcomes, or analytical AI, which provides insights from input data, generative AI is designed to produce original content that can be similar to human-created material. For example, the famous Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT)model can generate text almost indistinguishable from human written text. Typically, it works by taking a prompt as input and generating a corresponding output based on that prompt. Example of Using ChatGPT (The prompt is on the right, and the generated output is on the left)
Part 03 Background
Fast Facts The market for generative AI is expected to skyrocket to $207 billion by 2030, a massive increase from $5.67 billion in 2020[1]. Educational institutions are leading this growth, with 58% of university instructors already using AI tools in their daily teaching according to the latest statistics[2]. How generative AI is used in education Generative AI is widely used in education across several key areas: ·Student Support: AI-driven tutors assist with test prep, coding, and writing, while also offering mental health support. ·Grading & Feedback: AI provides instant feedback on homework and helps track student progress. ·Content Creation & Personalization: AI generates lessons, reading materials and analyzes student data to tailor learning plans. AI Integration in Education: A Map of Tools and Applications [3] Due to space constraints, some of the mentioned examples do not include detailed statistics or citations.
Part 04 Several things about Artificial Intelligence
Employment Some argue that artificial intelligence might take away jobs, particularly in roles involving repetitive and predictable tasks like customer services or jobs requiring high accuracy and reliability such as diagnosing diseases from medical images. However, AI also creates new industries and jobs like prompt engineers, and drive business expansions by lowering cost, potentially creating more jobs. Additionally, by automating mundane daily tasks, people can focus on more meaningful work. Privacy & Security Training AI requires large amounts of data, including biometrics(e.g., fingerprints, iris scans) and behavioral data (e.g., purchase / browse history). Usersʼ data are being collected without noting, as most people do not thoroughly read or understand privacy agreements. This extensive data aggregation can infringe on privacy, allowing AI models learn and predict personal behaviors such as voting preferences, which can then be used to manipulate online experiences like Youtube feeds. Improper data handling might also have security problems such as data leakage. Copyrights AI basically learns from existing data, extract their patterns and generate content similar to them, which raises serious copyright issues. For example, The New York Times has sued OpenAI and Microsoft for the unpermitted use of Times articles to train GPT large language model. Even if AI-generated output are not near-verbatim of original works, the synthetic output still derives from the original content, capturing implicit patterns. The extent to which AI usage infringes on original content remains significant issue, especially as AI-generated works are becoming more popular. Accountability If AI goes wrong, itʼs hard to determine who is responsible. Itʼs impossible to hold programmers accountable, since they only create the model architecture(AI is literally a black box) and do not do case-by-case test. Additionally, general public often lacks the capability to understand rationality of the model or have access to its specifics, making it harder for them to call AI out. This issue is particularly concerning in critical areas like military applications, healthcare and autonomous vehicles, where AI decisions are made in such short notice and have such profound impacts, making it essential to establish clear accountability. Bias AI models might prone to bias because they learn from historical data, which might have racist / sexist content. This lead to biased decision-making and discriminative analysis. For example, artificial intelligence used in criminal justice system would tend to impose harsher penalties on black defendants based on historical data showing higher recidivism rates. Whatʼs more, AI often lacks adequate data on minority groups, leading to unfair treatment. For example, facial recognition algorithms in the U.S. are more accurate for white people and less so for other ethnic groups.
Citation [1] Sharma, Nitin.*Generative AI in Education: Know Meaning, Benefits & Challenges.* Hurix Digital, June 12, 2024. [2] Wiley Newsroom.*Generative AI Already Being Used in Majority of College Classrooms, According to Instructors in New Wiley Survey.* Wiley, September 21, 2023. [3] Holt, Laurence.*A Map of Generative AI for Education: An Update to Our Map of the Current State-of-the-Art.* Medium, March 7, 2024. 想必经过本次Carol导师对辩题的解读后 各位辩手们一定对本次辩题有更深刻的认识 期待各位在辩论场上的精彩表现哦~